``The paper obviously addresses the physics community and
also uses its style. The author does not care if the things he
manipulates are defined or even make sense. This by
itself can be accepted. What is more serious in the reviewer's
eyes is the fact that he does not pay attention to the existing
mathematical literature on the same circle of
Dieter H. Mayer, Mathematical Reviews, review of E.B. Bogolmony, "Semiclassical quantization of multidimensional systems," Nonlinearity #5 (1992), 805-866.
ilan's home page